The Rupp Report: The Suffering Italian Fashion Industry
Jürg Rupp, Executive Editor
Having been in this industry for many decades, it has always been the same: When I was in Italy,
people asked me: "How is it in France? Are they good, are they fashionable?" Vice-versa in France,
same questions: "How is it in Italy? Are they good, are they fashionable?" This ping-pong was going
on and on, though an answer was almost impossible. Two fashion countries at the top, but with
totally different products and a totally different approach to the markets. These times, it seems,
are gone, at least for the near future. Today, it's more the question, who will survive?
Trouble For Big Labels
As many news agencies report, Italian fashion brands such as Gianfranco Ferré and Malo could be up for sale as owner IT Holding S.p.A. is in financial trouble and seeks a way out with the support of special administration. The rumor is that IT will refocus on production licenses through its Ittierre S.p.A. division. It is not excluded that a sale could be done before the restructuring plan is final, but that sale would need to be approved by the ministry. It could be done privately, but the favored method would be an auction. It is said that advisers and banks have already contacted the commissioners.
IT Holding is in the hands of three administrators appointed by the industry ministry last month. They have six months to draw up a restructuring plan for the group. IT Holding looked unsuccessfully for a partner for months. It had net debt of 295.4 million euros at the end of September and a nine-month net loss of 10.1 million euros. Late in February, it secured a credit line of 30 million euros.
Ferré, renowned for his special "architectural" style, passed away in 2007 and his eponymous label is now styled by Tommaso Aquilano and Roberto Rimondi. Their womenswear show in February, watched by the commissioners, was well-received. Ferré's revenues were 104 million euros in the first nine months of 2008, while knitwear brand Malo had 35.7 million euros out of total revenues of 468 million euros. An offer of 120 million to 140 million euros for Ferre was made by a private equity firm in December 2008 but was rejected.
As the US government has been injecting billions of dollars into banks and car companies, the Italian government is placing its pennies on the fashion industry and is planning special measures to support the fashion industry through the crisis. The main support will be a tax credit to ease the production of apparel samples and collections, and the government also will allow access for fashion houses to a fund for small and medium-sized enterprises.
The target of the measures is to save the endangered "Made in Italy" fashion sector and generate the conditions to allow companies to be more competitive on international markets after the crisis. Last month, Italian apparel and textile companies called on the government to support their sector, which has been hit by a drying-up of credit and a slump in demand for fashion.
With 800,000 workers in all levels of this industry ready to benefit, the Italian government may offer full salary to laid-off workers and tax breaks for women. Government subsidies for small companies also might be included. The government is willing to offer $2 billion to support small companies overall, and some of that would go to the fashion industry.
Poor(er) Fashion Week In Milan
The catwalks in Italy are also in danger owing to IT's problems. Just Cavalli, the label of designer Roberto Cavalli, was absent. He was forced to cancel the show of the company's younger range of clothing after its distributor, Ittierre, was put into administration.
The Milan Fashion Week was and is more of a poor event this year, as the Italian apparel industry struggles with the impact of the global financial crisis. This year, there were fewer fashion shows, with many firms opting for modest exhibitions, according to the Italian Chamber of Fashion. At the men's show in January, there were one-fifth fewer shows than the year before. Although Italy is known for its international brands such as Giorgio Armani, Versace, and Gucci, smaller labels dominate the market, and this sector has been devastated more by the global downturn.
Last month, the Italian Chamber of Fashion warned revenues for the sector would fall at least 5 percent this year, and now the crisis has claimed its first big fashion victim in Italy, with IT Holding's distribution subsidiary, Ittierre, under bankruptcy protection.
March 24, 2009